As the beloved host of The Price Is Right, Drew Carey has seen it all—or so he thought. Having helmed the legendary game show since 2007, Carey is no stranger to strange on-stage antics, eccentric contestants, and unpredictable moments. But even a seasoned host like him isn’t immune to the occasional moment that completely throws him off guard.

In a recent episode of the long-running CBS game show, one particular contestant made a lasting impression—not for her gameplay, but for her bizarre choice of outfit. The shirt she wore onstage creeped out not just the audience, but Drew Carey himself, who couldn’t hide his reaction.

The contestant’s shirt featured an image of someone dressed up as Drew Carey himself—a detail she proudly pointed out. Apparently, one of her friends had dressed up as the host, and she decided to feature that image on her custom shirt. The visual was jarring enough for Carey to address it live, turning to announcer George Gray and saying, “It’s like looking in a funhouse mirror, George.”

While Carey kept the mood light, his visible discomfort was apparent to anyone watching. The strange moment served as a reminder that The Price Is Right is not just about guessing prices—it’s also a stage for some of the most unusual personalities in daytime television.

This wasn’t the first time Carey had to deal with an out-of-the-ordinary contestant. Over the years, he has openly shared that many of the show’s participants often show up under the influence of alcohol or other substances. Since audience members never know for sure if they’ll be called to “Come on Down,” some try to calm their nerves with a few drinks—or even more questionable methods. One contestant in the past even admitted to being high on mushrooms during his appearance.

Despite the occasional weird moment, Carey has remained professional and upbeat, always handling the unexpected with humor and grace. Still, this recent encounter seemed to throw him off just enough to become a viral talking point among fans of the show.

The contestant in question managed to advance past the initial pricing game by picking two of the smallest items, which earned her a short-lived victory. Unfortunately, her luck didn’t hold during the iconic spinning wheel round, and she failed to move on to the showcase showdown. Still, her appearance—and more specifically, her eye-catching and eerie shirt—made sure she wouldn’t be forgotten anytime soon.

For many viewers, this was a hilarious highlight of the episode. Social media lit up with fans reacting to Carey’s stunned expression and his funhouse mirror comparison. “I’ve never seen Drew look so thrown off,” one user commented. Others praised Carey’s quick wit and his ability to laugh through the awkwardness.

Moments like these are part of what keeps The Price Is Right so entertaining after more than 50 seasons. With Drew Carey at the helm, the show continues to embrace the quirky, the unexpected, and yes, the downright creepy. Whether contestants are bringing unusual fashion statements or just unpredictable energy, the legendary host knows better than anyone—when it comes to The Price Is Right, expect the unexpected.